
Prof. Dion Forster on Faith Amid Disappointment: When Prayers Seem Unanswered
Loading player...
In this episode, the host in Amsterdam/Stellenbosch chats with Professor Dion Forster about what happens when our prayers seem unanswered or the answer isn't what we hope for — exploring faith amid disappointment. Prof. Forster shares that many people he knows in the Netherlands and South Africa are going through tough times: health struggles, a friend who was retrenched and can't find work, someone struggling with a child. As Christians, we pray about these things, doing what Paul tells us in Philippians — make your requests known to God, and the peace of God which passes all understanding will keep your hearts and minds in Christ Jesus. But sometimes the things we pray for don't work out as we hoped. He shares a light humorous story: Billy Graham's wife reportedly said, "Thank goodness God didn't answer my prayer every time, otherwise I would have married the wrong man several times before I married Billy Graham." He then turns to 2 Corinthians 12:8–9: "Three times I pleaded with the Lord to take this affliction away from me, but he said to me, My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness." Biblical scholars aren't sure what Paul's affliction was — possibly epilepsy, or an intestinal problem — but we know Paul lived his whole life with it, yet was deeply faithful, a committed apostle who knew God's power. He prayed repeatedly for relief, modeling what we are told to do, but God's response was not to remove the suffering but to give him a promise even greater than the suffering. Prof. Forster explains two possible options when we come to God in prayer: (1) sometimes we think God is silent — but the Psalms tell us God is not silent, He is working behind the scenes, not absent but busy working something out, and maybe it's not yet the right time; (2) sometimes God does answer, but the answer is not the one we wanted. God is not an Uber driver, not ChatGPT that says "What a great idea, let's go with that" — God is the God of the whole universe, who knows what is good, right, and necessary. He is cautious about telling people "God is working out something better," because that's not always true — sometimes suffering is just the way things are; all of us will age and eventually be unable to do what we could in our prime. What we can ask is: "Lord, in the midst of the reality of life, its suffering and its joys, would you give me sufficient grace to deal with it?" He suggests that sometimes our view of prayer is theologically wrong: we think the purpose of prayer is to change God, when in fact the purpose of prayer is for God to change us. Sometimes what we go through does work out for good — that's the promise — but it might be a good of a slightly different kind. Prayer is genuinely asking God to act, and sometimes God's act is to make us fuller, wholer, deeper, more mature, better people. He points to Jesus in the Garden of Gethsemane: "Lord, if you can take this cup from me... not my will, but your will be done." He closes with three encouragements: (1) keep praying honestly — God doesn't want to hear something other than the truth; (2) be careful to interpret disappointment as God's deliberate decision — disappointments along the way are not the ultimate end; (3) constantly look out for God's grace in whatever circumstance you face. His closing word: "God is very close to you, He is listening, and His desire is to bless you and work in your life for His purposes, which are ultimately good for you too." The conversation ends with a light exchange about AI — ChatGPT telling you your ideas are amazing, the meme about eating a poisonous mushroom, and a colleague who is polite to machines "just in case one day they take over."

